Felt Tip vs Brush Tip Eyeliner

The type of eyeliner tip you choose can make or break your makeup game. Doesn’t matter!  Whether you’re a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, selecting between felt tip vs brush tip eyeliners can be tricky. 

Fear not! You no longer have to struggle to decide which one suits you best. This post explores the debate between the popular eyeliners, felt tip and brush tip eyeliners.

Get ready to learn the secrets of precision and versatility for your eye makeup.

Felt Tip vs Brush Tip Eyeliner: Comparing Performance and Results

Precision and control

Felt tip eyeliners provide precise lines with consistent thickness. Their firm, pointed tips allow for controlled application, making them ideal for creating sharp wings and intricate details. However, they may lack the flexibility to vary line thickness as effortlessly as brush tip eyeliners.

Brush tip eyeliners offer superior flexibility, allowing for precise control over line thickness and shape. With their fine, tapered bristles, brush tip eyeliners enable you to adjust the pressure to achieve thin and thick lines effortlessly. This versatility makes them ideal for achieving intricate designs and customized looks with ease.

Ease of application

Felt tip eyeliners work best if you are a beginner because of their ease of use. The firm tip provides stability and requires minimal effort to create smooth, even lines. Their user-friendly design makes them suitable if you are new to applying eyeliner or struggling with shaky hands.

Brush tip eyeliners may have a steeper learning curve, but their smooth application and flexibility offer advantages for experienced users. With practice, controlling the brush tip becomes intuitive, allowing for effortless application and the creation of precise lines. Brush tip eyeliners are preferred by makeup artists and enthusiasts seeking more intricate and customized looks.

Durability and longevity

Felt tip eyeliners often contain long-lasting formulas that resist smudging and fading throughout the day. The firm tip ensures consistent pigment delivery, resulting in a bold and defined look that maintains its intensity for hours without requiring touch-ups.

Brush tip eyeliners also offer excellent longevity, provided they are well-maintained. Their fluid application and customizable thickness allow buildable coverage that adheres well to the skin, so you don’t have to worry about lasting wear without flaking or smudging.

Versatility in styles

Felt tip eyeliners are well-suited for creating classic, clean lines and sharp wings. While they may lack the fluidity of brush tip eyeliners, they excel in delivering precise, graphic looks that emphasize definition and structure.

Brush tip eyeliners shine in versatility, offering the ability to create a wide range of styles, from subtle and natural to bold and dramatic. Their flexible bristles enable you to experiment with different line thicknesses, shapes, and finishes.

Suitability for different eye shapes and makeup looks

Felt tip eyeliners are generally suitable for all eye shapes, particularly those with smaller or hooded eyes. Their precision and ease of control make them ideal for accentuating the lash line and creating precise flicks that complement various makeup looks.

Brush tip eyeliners offer versatility that caters to different eye shapes and preferences. Their ability to create thin and thick lines allows for customization based on individual features. This means you can enhance the eyes’ natural shape or create bold, statement looks.

Read also: Lip Balm vs Chapstick.


What’s the main difference between felt tip and brush tip eyeliners?

Felt tip eyeliners feature a firm, marker-like tip made of felt or foam, offering precise and consistent lines with limited flexibility in thickness. On the other hand, brush tip eyeliners have soft, flexible bristles that resemble a paintbrush, allowing for versatile line thickness and artistic control.

Which type of eyeliner is better for beginners?

Felt tip eyeliners are often recommended for beginners due to their user-friendly design and ease of application. The firm tip provides stability, making creating smooth, even lines easier without requiring advanced techniques. Besides, felt tip eyeliners typically offer more control over line thickness, helping beginners achieve precise results with minimal effort.

Can you achieve a winged eyeliner look with both types?

Yes, both felt tip and brush tip eyeliners can be used to achieve a winged eyeliner look. Felt tip eyeliners are well-suited for creating sharp, graphic wings due to their precision and ability to maintain consistent line thickness. Similarly, brush tip eyeliners offer more flexibility in creating winged looks. You get smoother transitions and customizable thicknesses. 

Which type of eyeliner is suitable for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers?

If you have sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, choose an eyeliner formula that is gentle and non-irritating. Water-based felt tip eyeliners tend to be more suitable for sensitive eyes, as they are less likely to cause irritation or allergic reactions. Ensure the liquid liner is for the eye labelled as hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested to minimize the risk of discomfort or adverse reactions.

What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?

Gel or liquid eyeliners with waterproof or long-wearing formulas are perfect for all-day wear. Look for eyeliners specifically marketed as smudge-proof, waterproof, or long-lasting because these formulations are designed to withstand humidity, sweat, and oil production throughout the day. You can also use an eyelid primer or setting powder to enhance the staying power of your eyeliner. 

Leave a Comment